| Baseball | Eppa Rixey | Baseball Hall of Fame | 1963 |
| | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1972 |
| Melvin Roach | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1988 |
| Ryan Zimmerman | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2023 |
| Football | Joe Palumbo | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1973 |
| Bill Dudley | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1974 |
| Henry Jordan | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1974 |
| Track | Harrison Flippen | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1975 |
| J.C. Herbert Bryant | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1984 |
| Men's Basketball | Richard Wilkinson | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1975 |
| Julius Conn | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1976 |
| Ralph Sampson | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1996 |
| | National Collegiate Basketball Hall of Fame | 2011 |
| | Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame | 2012 |
| Barry Parkhill | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2001 |
| Terry Holland | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2003 |
| Bryant Stith | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2007 |
| Football | Bill Dudley | College Football Hall of Fame | 1956 |
| | Professional Football Hall of Fame | 1966 |
| Earle “Greasy” Neale | College Football Hall of Fame | 1967 |
| | Professional Football Hall of Fame | 1969 |
| Eugene Mayer | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1980 |
| James Gillette Jr. | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1983 |
| Frank Murray | College Football Hall of Fame | 1983 |
| J.C. Herbert Bryant | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1984 |
| William Thomas | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1985 |
| William Gooch | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1986 |
| Thomas Scott | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1989 |
| | College Football Hall of Fame | 1979 |
| Ulmo “Sonny” Randle | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1991 |
| Henry Jordan | Professional Football Hall of Fame | 1995 |
| Joe Palumbo | College Football Hall of Fame | 1999 |
| W.H. “Hank” Norton | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2006 |
| George Welsh | College Football Hall of Fame | 2004 |
| | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2009 |
| Jim Dombrowski | College Football Hall of Fame | 2008 |
| | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2010 |
| Herman Moore | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2010 |
| Tiki Barber | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2011 |
| | CoSIDA Academic All-America Hall of Fame | 2014 |
| James Ferrior | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2016 |
| Heath Miller | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2018 |
| Billy Baber | Virginia High School Hall of Fame | 2019 |
| Anthony Poindexter | College Football Hall of Fame | 2020 |
| | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2022 |
| Shawn Moore | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2023 |
| Ronde Barber | Professional Football Hall of Fame | 2023 |
| Men's Lacrosse | Howdy Myers | National Lacrosse Hall of Fame | 1971 |
| Bill Hooper | National Lacrosse Hall of Fame | 1976 |
| Pete Eldredge | National Lacrosse Hall of Fame | 1990 |
| Jay Connor | National Lacrosse Hall of Fame | 1994 |
| Jim Potter | National Lacrosse Hall of Fame | 1997 |
| John Driscoll | National Lacrosse Hall of Fame | 1998 |
| Doyle Smith | National Lacrosse Hall of Fame | 2000 |
| Tom Duquette | National Lacrosse Hall of Fame | 2001 |
| | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2009 |
| Roddy Marino | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2002 |
| Eugene Corrigan | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2007 |
| Dom Starsia | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2008 |
| | IMLCA Hall of Fame | 2020 |
| Michael Watson | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2013 |
| Jay Jalbert | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2014 |
| Doug Knight | National Lacrosse Hall of Fame | 2017 |
| | NILCA Hall of Fame | 2021 |
| Doug Terring | NILCA Hall of Fame | 2021 |
| Kris Snider | National Lacrosse Hall of Fame | 2022 |
| Men's Soccer | Mike Fisher | CoSIDA Academic All-America Hall of Fame | 1996 |
| John Harkes | National Soccer Hall of Fame | 2005 |
| Jeff Agoos | National Soccer Hall of Fame | 2011 |
| Tony Meola | National Soccer Hall of Fame | 2012 |
| Claudio Reyna | National Soccer Hall of Fame | 2012 |
| | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2017 |
| Men's Tennis | C. Alphonso Smith | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1987 |
| Harold Burrows Jr. | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 1990 |
| Somdev Devvarman | ITA Men’s Hall of Fame | 2019 |
| Women's Basketball | Dawn Staley | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2008 |
| | Women’s Basketball Hall of Fame | 2012 |
| | Naismith Hall of Fame | 2013 |
| Debbie Ryan | Women’s Basketball Hall of Fame | 2008 |
| | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2012 |
| Val Ackerman | Academic All-America Hall of Fame | 1999 |
| | Women’s Basketball Hall of Fame | 2011 |
| | CoSIDA Academic All-America Hall of Fame | 2011 |
| | Naismith Hall of Fame | 2021 |
| Field Hockey | Michele Madison | NFHCA Hall of Fame | 2013 |
| Women's Lacrosse | Julie Williams | National Hall of Fame | 2002 |
| Heather Dow | National Hall of Fame | 2002 |
| Jane Miller | National Hall of Fame | 2003 |
| | IWLCA Hall of Fame | 2019 |
| Cherlie Greer Brown | National Hall of Fame | 2009 |
| | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2015 |
| | US Lacrosse Hall of Fame | 2015 |
| Bonnie Rosen | National Hall of Fame | 2010 |
| Robyn Nye | US Lacrosse Hall of Fame | 2017 |
| Kara Ariza Cooke | National Lacrosse Hall of Fame | 2019 |
| Amy Appelt Slade | National Lacrosse Hall of Fame | 2020 |
| Rowing | Lindsay Shoop | National Rowing Hall of Fame | 2014 |
| Kevin Sauer | Pocock/CRCA Hall of Fame | 2017 |
| Women's Soccer | Angela Hucles | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2015 |
| SID | Rich Murray | Virginia Sports Hall of Fame | 2016 |
| Athletic Director | Craig Littlepaige | NACDA Hall of Fame | 2021 |
