| Baseball | Dennis Womack | 1985 |
| Brian O’Connor | 2004 |
| Brian O’Connor | 2010 |
| Brian O’Connor | 2011 |
| Brian O’Connor | 2013 |
| Brian O’Connor | 2014 |
| Men's Basketball | Bill Gibson | 1972 |
| Terry Holland | 1981 |
| Terry Holland | 1982 |
| Dave Leitao | 2007 |
| Tony Bennett | 2014 |
| Tony Bennett | 2015 |
| Tony Bennett | 2018 |
| Tony Bennett | 2019 |
| Men's Cross Country | Dennis Craddock | 1984 |
| Dennis Craddock | 1985 |
| Jason Dunn | 2005 |
| Jason Dunn | 2007 |
| Jason Vigilante | 2008 |
| Football | Bill Elias | 1961 |
| George Blackburn | 1968 |
| George Welsh | 1983 |
| George Welsh | 1984 |
| George Welsh | 1989 |
| George Welsh | 1991 |
| George Welsh | 1995 |
| Al Groh | 2002 |
| Al Groh | 2007 |
| Mike London | 2011 |
| Men's Golf | Mike Moraghan | 1992 |
| Bowen Sargent | 2010 |
| Men's Lacrosse | Jim Adams | 1990 |
| Dom Starsia | 1995 |
| Dom Starsia | 1996 |
| Dom Starsia | 1999 |
| Dom Starsia | 2000 |
| Dom Starsia | 2002 |
| Dom Starsia | 2003 |
| Dom Starsia | 2006 |
| Dom Starsia | 2009 |
| Lars Tiffany | 2019 |
| Lars Tiffany | 2022 |
| Men's Outdoor Track & Field | Dennis Craddock | 1984 |
| Randy Bungard | 2001 |
| Jason Vigilante | 2009 |
| Bryan Fetzer | 2019 |
| Men's Soccer | Bruce Arena | 1979 |
| Bruce Arena | 1984 |
| Bruce Arena | 1986 |
| Bruce Arena | 1988 |
| Bruce Arena | 1989 |
| Bruce Arena | 1991 |
| Bruce Arena | 1995 |
| George Gelnovatch | 1996 |
| George Gelnovatch | 2001 |
| Men's Swimming & Diving | Mark Bernardino | 1983 |
| Mark Bernardino | 1984 |
| Mark Bernardino | 1987 |
| Mark Bernardino | 1988 |
| Mark Bernardino | 1989 |
| Mark Bernardino | 1994 |
| Mark Bernardino | 1999 |
| Mark Bernardino | 2000 |
| Mark Bernardino | 2001 |
| Mark Bernardino | 2002 |
| Mark Bernardino | 2003 |
| Mark Bernardino | 2004 |
| Mark Bernardino | 2005 |
| Mark Bernardino | 2006 |
| Mark Bernardino | 2008 |
| Mark Bernardino | 2009 |
| Mark Bernardino | 2010 |
| Mark Bernardino | 2011 |
| Men's Tennis | Gordon Burris | 1969 |
| Brian Boland | 2005 |
| Brian Boland | 2008 |
| Brian Boland | 2009 |
| Brian Boland | 2010 |
| Brian Boland | 2011 |
| Brian Boland | 2012 |
| Andres Pedroso | 2019 |
| Andres Pedroso | 2021 |
| Andres Pedroso | 2022 |
| Wrestling | Steve Garland | 2010 |
| Women's Basketball | Debbie Ryan | 1984 |
| Debbie Ryan | 1986 |
| Debbie Ryan | 1987 |
| Debbie Ryan | 1991 |
| Debbie Ryan | 1993 |
| Debbie Ryan | 1995 |
| Debbie Ryan | 2000 |
| Women's Cross Country | Todd Morgan | 2013 |
| Field Hockey | Missi Sanders | 1997 |
| Michele Madison | 2017 |
| Women's Golf | Jan Mann | 2005 |
| Kim Lewellen | 2008 |
| Kim Lewellen | 2015 |
| Kim Lewellen | 2016 |
| Women's Indoor Track & Field | Fred Binggeli | 1987 |
| Fred Binggeli | 1994 |
| Women's Lacrosse | Julie Myers | 2002 |
| Julie Myers | 2003 |
| Julie Myers | 2005 |
| Julie Myers | 2007 |
| Julie Myers | 2013 |
| Julie Myers | 2014 |
| Julie Myers | 2019 |
| Women's Outdoor Track & Field | Dennis Craddock | 1984 |
| Dennis Craddock | 1985 |
| Doug Williamson | 1986 |
| Fred Binggeli | 1990 |
| Fred Binggeli (Co-COY) | 1995 |
| Rowing | Kevin Sauer | 2000 |
| Kevin Sauer | 2003 |
| Kevin Sauer | 2004 |
| Kevin Sauer | 2007 |
| Kevin Sauer | 2010 |
| Kevin Sauer | 2011 |
| Kevin Sauer | 2012 |
| Kevin Sauer | 2013 |
| Kevin Sauer | 2014 |
| Kevin Sauer | 2015 |
| Kevin Sauer | 2018 |
| Kevin Sauer | 2022 |
| Women's Soccer | Lauren Gregg | 1989 |
| Steve Swanson | 2013 |
| Steve Swanson | 2015 |
| Softball | Peggy Kellers | 1994 |
| Women's Swimming & Diving | Mark Bernardino | 1983 |
| Mark Bernardino | 1984 |
| Mark Bernardino | 1986 |
| Mark Bernardino | 1990 |
| Mark Bernardino | 1994 |
| Mark Bernardino | 1996 |
| Mark Bernardino | 1998 |
| Mark Bernardino | 1999 |
| Mark Bernardino | 2003 |
| Mark Bernardino | 2008 |
| Mark Bernardino | 2009 |
| Mark Bernardino | 2010 |
| Mark Bernardino | 2011 |
| Augie Busch | 2014 |
| Augie Busch | 2015 |
| Augie Busch | 2016 |
| Todd DeSorbo | 2020 |
| Todd DeSorbo | 2021 |
| Todd DeSorbo | 2022 |
| Todd DeSorbo | 2023 |
| Women's Tennis | Mark Guildeau | 2006 |
