| Baseball | Danny Hultzen | 2009 | |
| Joe McCarthy | 2013 | |
| Men's Basketball | Ralph Sampson | 1980 | |
| Bryant Smith | 1989 | |
| Chris Williams | 1999 | |
| Sylven Landesberg | 2009 | |
| Men's Cross Country | Andy Biladeau | 2005 | |
| Emil Heineking | 2007 | |
| Conner Rog | 2012 | |
| Thomas Madden | 2013 | |
| Lachlan Cook | 2016 | |
| Football | John Ford | 1984 | |
| Ronde Barber | 1994 | |
| Quin Blanding | 2014 | Defensive Rookie of the Year |
| | | Coaches Defensive Rookie of the Year |
| Brenton Nelson | 2017 | Defensive Rookie of the Year |
| Men's Golf | Jimmy Flippen | 1992 | |
| Lewis Chitengwa | 1995 | |
| Denny McCarthy | 2012 | |
| Ben James | 2023 | |
| Men's Indoor Track & Field | Robby Andrews | 2010 | |
| Men's Lacrosse | Matthew Nunes | 2022 | |
| Men's Outdoor Track & Field | Robby Andrews | 2010 | |
| Anthony Kostelac | 2011 | |
| Filip Mihaljevic | 2014 | |
| Men's Soccer | Claudio Reyna | 1991 | |
| Jason Moore | 1997 | |
| Kyle Martino | 1999 | |
| Alecko Eskandarian | 2000 | |
| Tony Tchani | 2008 | |
| Men's Swimming & Diving | Donak Finch | 1997 | |
| Ed Moses | 1999 | |
| Luke Wagner | 2001 | |
| Bo Greenwood | 2002 | |
| Fran Crippen | 2003 | |
| Vanja Rogulj | 2004 | |
| Pat Mellors | 2005 | |
| Matt McLean | 2008 | |
| Men's Tennis | Brain Vahaly | 1998 | |
| Doug Stewart | 2003 | |
| Somdev Devvarman | 2005 | |
| Alex Domijan | 2011 | |
| Mitchell Frank | 2012 | |
| Brandon Nakashima | 2019 | |
| Dylan Dietrich | 2024 | |
| Wrestling | Eric Albright | 2006 | |
| Chris Henrich | 2008 | |
| Jack Mueller | 2017 | |
| Women's Basketball | Dawn Staley | 1989 | |
| Tora Suber | 1994 | |
| Schuye LaRue | 2000 | |
| Brandi Teamer | 2002 | |
| Monica Wright | 2007 | |
| Women's Cross Country | Maria Hauger | 2013 | |
| Field Hockey | Meredith Thrope | 1995 | |
| Meredith Elwell | 1995 | |
| Paige Selenski | 2008 | |
| Lucy Hyams | 2013 | |
| Tara Vittese | 2014 | |
| Pien Dicke | 2017 | |
| Women's Indoor Track & Field | Jada Seaman | 2020 | Field |
| Women's Lacrosse | Amy Fromal | 1997 | |
| Mills Hook | 1998 | |
| Caitlin Banks | 2001 | |
| Amy Appelt | 2002 | |
| Blair Weymouth | 2006 | |
| Brittany Kalkstein | 2007 | |
| Rachel Vander Kolk | 2015 | |
| Sammy Mueller | 2017 | |
| Kate Galica | 2024 | |
| Women's Outdoor Track & Field | Morgane Gay | 2009 | |
| Mia Barnett | 2022 | |
| Rowing | Jennifer Cromwell | 2007 | |
| Martha Kuzzy | 2009 | |
| Kristine O'Brien | 2010 | |
| Georgia Ratcliff | 2014 | |
| Hedi Long | 2016 | |
| Women's Soccer | Becky Sauerbrunn | 2003 | |
| Jess Rostedt | 2005 | |
| Morgan Brian | 2011 | |
| Softball | Kristen Dennis | 1999 | |
| Ruby Rojas | 2000 | |
| Women's Swimming & Diving | Danica Wizniuk | 1999 | |
| Mirjana Bosevska | 2000 | |
| Rachel Burke | 2003 | |
| Kimi Kelly | 2004 | |
| Liz Shaw | 2008 | |
| Lauren Perdue | 2010 | |
| Ellen Williamson | 2012 | |
| Courtney Bartholomew | 2013 | |
| Leah Smith | 2014 | |
| Jennifer Marrkand | 2015 | |
| Kate Douglass | 2020 | |
| Alex Walsh | 2021 | |
| Gretchen Walsh | 2022 | |
| Aimee Canny | 2023 | |
| Women's Tennis | Julia Elbaba | 2013 | |
| Emma Navarro | 2021 | |
| Volleyball | Sarah Kirkwood | 2004 | |
| McKenzie Adams | 2010 | |
| Jasmine Burton | 2013 | |
