| Sport | Athlete | Year |
|---|---|---|
| Football (Jim Tatum Award) | Bert Krupp | 1981 |
| Pat Chester | 1982 | |
| David Cardenas | 1986 | |
| Tom Burns | 1993 | |
| Stephen Phelan | 1997 | |
| Noel LaMontagne | 1999 | |
| Tom Santi | 2007 | |
| Jordan Mack | 2017 | |
| Will Bettridge | 2025 | |
| Men's Cross Country | Gary Martin | 2024 |
| Men's Indoor Track & Field | Owayne Owens | 2023 |
| Gary Martin | 2026 | |
| Men's Lacrosse | Ben Rubeor | 2008 |
| Danny Glading | 2009 | |
| Ryan Conrad | 2019 | |
| Connor Shellenberger | 2023 | |
| Men's Outdoor Track & Field | Filip Milhaljevic | 2017 |
| Ethan Dabbs | 2023 | |
| Men's Soccer | Joe Bell | 2019 |
| Men's Swimming & Diving | Howard Means | 1965 |
| Bob Lyon | 1977 | |
| Mathias Bostrom | 1985 | |
| Shamek Pietucha | 1999 | |
| Austin Ramirez | 2000 | |
| P.J. Sullivan | 2008 | |
| David Karasek | 2012 | |
| Men's Tennis | Dominic Inglot | 2008 |
| Dominic Inglot | 2009 | |
| Mitchell Frank | 2014 | |
| Thai-Son Kwiatkowski | 2016 | |
| Thai-Son Kwiatkowski | 2017 | |
| Carl Soderlund | 2019 | |
| Carl Soderlund | 2021 | |
| Chris Rodesch | 2023 | |
| Chris Rodesch | 2024 | |
| Wrestling | Matt Snyder | 2012 |
| Matt Snyder | 2013 | |
| Women's Basketball | Jocelyn Willoughby | 2020 |
| Field Hockey | Mary Jo Adams | 1983 |
| Lesley Groff | 1988 | |
| Kelly Daddona | 1993 | |
| Heather Hale | 1996 | |
| Peggy Boutilier | 1997 | |
| Lori Mastropietro | 1998 | |
| Rachel Robinson | 2019 | |
| Jans Croon | 2024 | |
| 2025 | ||
| Women's Lacrosse | Courtney Swan | 2015 |
| Women's Outdoor Track & Field | Cleo Boyd | 2016 |
| Michaela Meyer | 2021 | |
| Rowing | Kelsie Chaudion | 2008 |
| Jennifer Cromwell | 2010 | |
| Sarah Borchelt | 2011 | |
| Sarah Borchelt | 2012 | |
| Sarah Cowburn | 2013 | |
| Tessa Dikkers | 2016 | |
| Georgia Ratcliff | 2017 | |
| Heidi Long | 2019 | |
| Sophia Kershner | 2021 | |
| Nicola Lawless | 2022 | |
| Women's Soccer | Makenzy Doniak | 2015 |
| Alexa Spaanstra | 2020 | |
| Women's Swimming & Diving | Carol Frost | 1985 |
| Lori Werth | 1993 | |
| Megan Roesch | 2002 | |
| Mirjana Bosevska | 2003 | |
| Amy Baly | 2004 | |
| Mei Christensen | 2010 | |
| Paige Madden | 2020 | |
| Paige Madden | 2021 | |
| Kate Douglass | 2022 | |
| Kate Douglass | 2023 | |
| Gretchen Walsh | 2024 | |
| Gretchen Walsh | 2025 | |
| Claire Curzan | 2026 |
