Academic All-Americans
| Year | Athlete | Sport | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1966 | Don Parker | Football | 2nd |
| Fred Jones | Football | HM | |
| Ken Postas | Football | HM | |
| 1970 | Steve Bryant | Baseball | 1st |
| 1972 | Tom Kennedy | Football | 1st |
| Mike Judkins | Baseball | 3rd | |
| 1973 | Jim Hobgood | Men's Basketball | 2nd |
| 1975 | Bob Meade | Football | 1st |
| 1976 | Wally Walker | Men's Basketball | 1st |
| 1979 | Pat Chester | Football | 2nd |
| 1980 | Val Ackerman | Women's Basketball | 2nd |
| Lee Raker | Men's Basketball | HM | |
| 1981 | Jeff Lamp | Men's Basketball | 1st |
| Lee Raker | Men's Basketball | 1st | |
| Val Ackerman | Women's Basketball | 1st | |
| 1982 | Ed Reynolds | Football | 2nd |
| Kevin Clarke | Baseball | 3rd | |
| 1983 | Kevin Clarke | Baseball | 3rd |
| Jim Pagano | Wrestling (At-Large) | 3rd | |
| Cathy Grimes | Women's Basketball | HM | |
| 1984 | Kevin Clarke | Baseball | 1st |
| Mathias Bostrom | Men's Swimming (At-Large) | 3rd | |
| Martha Schmitt | Women's Track & Field (At-Large) | 3rd | |
| 1985 | Judith Ellen Browne | Softball | 2nd |
| Margaret Llvy | Softball | HM | |
| 1989 | Robin Bergen | Softball | 2nd |
| Lisa Palmer | Softball | 2nd | |
| 1990 | Richard Sharff | Baseball | 2nd |
| 1992 | Tom Burns | Football | 1st |
| Heather Burge | Women's Basketball | 2nd | |
| Tammi Reiss | Women's Basketball | 3rd | |
| 1993 | Tom Burns | Football | 1st |
| Dena Evans | Women's Basketball | 1st | |
| Heather Burge | Women's Basketball | 2nd | |
| 1994 | Rob Cook | Men's Cross Country (At-Large) | 2nd |
| 1995 | Tiki Barber | Football | 1st |
| Jenny Boucek | Women's Basketball | 3rd | |
| 1996 | Tiki Barber | Football | 1st |
| Mike Fisher* | Men's Soccer (At-Large) | 1st | |
| Jenny Boucek | Women's Basketball | 2nd | |
| Jamie Hahn | Softball | 2nd | |
| Chris Garber | Men's Swimming (At-Large) | 3rd | |
| 1997 | Mike Fisher* | Men's Soccer (At-Large) | 1st |
| Stephen Phelan Jr. | Football | 1st | |
| Heather Helen Hale | Field Hockey (At-Large) | 2nd | |
| Scott Lebovitz | Men's Tennis (At-Large) | 2nd | |
| Andriy Shapowal | Men's Soccer (At-Large) | 2nd | |
| 1998 | Margaret Boutilier | Women's Lacrosse (At-Large) | 1st |
| Andriy Shapowal | Men's Soccer (At-Large) | 1st | |
| 2000 | Austin Ramirez | Men's Swimming (At-Large) | 2nd |
| Amy Lynne Fromal | Women's Lacrosse (At-Large) | 3rd | |
| 2001 | David Stone | Baseball | 3rd |
| Kathleen Tracy | Women's Soccer (At-Large) | 3rd | |
| 2002 | Mark Koontz | Men's Lacrosse (At-Large) | 2nd |
| David Stone | Baseball | 2nd | |
| Megan Roesch | Women's Swimming (At-Large) | 3rd | |
| 2003 | Lauren Aumiller | Women's Lacrosse (At-Large) | 3rd |
| 2004 | Gillian Hatch | Women's Soccer | 2nd |
| 2005 | Sarah Kirkwood | Volleyball | 2nd |
| 2006 | Sarah Kirkwood | Volleyball | 1st |
| 2007 | Sarah Kirkwood | Volleyball | 2nd |
| Andrew Dumm | Men's Cross Country | 3rd | |
| Ben Rubeor | Men's Lacrosse (At-Large) | 3rd | |
| Leah Wigger | Women's Golf (At-Large) | 3rd | |
| 2008 | Ben Rubeor | Men's Lacrosse (At-Large) | 2nd |
| 2010 | Danny Hultzen | Baseball | 2nd |
| 2011 | Danny Hultzen | Baseball | 1st |
| 2012 | Sarah Borchelt | Rowing (At-Large) | 1st |
| Anna Corrigan | Women's Track & Field | 3rd | |
| Matt Snyder | Wrestling (At-Large) | 3rd | |
| 2013 | Sarah Cowburn | Rowing (At-Large) | 1st |
| Mark Amirault | Men's Track & Field | 3rd | |
| Matt Snyder | Wrestling (At-Large) | 3rd | |
| 2014 | Danielle Colaprico | Women's Soccer | 2nd |
| 2015 | Makenzy Doniak | Women's Soccer | 2nd |
| Courtney Swan | Women's Lacrosse | 3rd | |
| 2016 | Micah Kiser | Football | 2nd |
| 2017 | Kurt Benkert | Football | 2nd |
| 2019 | Meghan McCool | Women's Soccer | 2nd |
| 2020 | Sammy Mueller | Women's Lacrosse (At-Large) | 2nd |
| Carl Soderlund | Men's Tennis (At-Large) | 2nd | |
| Paige Madden | Women's Swimming (At-Large) | 3rd | |
| Ted Schubert | Men's Swimming (At-Large) | 3rd | |
| Jocelyn Willoughby | Women's Basketball | 3rd | |
| 2021 | Paige Madden | Women's Swimming (At-Large) | 1st |
| Carl Soderlund | Men's Tennis (At-Large) | 1st | |
| Michaela Meyer | Women's Cross Country | 2nd | |
| Owayne Owens | Men's Track & Field | 2nd | |
| 2022 | Jake Gelof | Baseball | 1st |
| Owayne Owens | Men's Track & Field | 1st | |
| Natasha Subhash | Women's Tennis (At-Large) | 2nd | |
| 2023 | Lexi Cuomo | Women's Swimming (At-Large) | 1st |
| Kate Douglass | Women's Swimming | 1st | |
| Jake Gelof | Baseball (At-Large) | 1st | |
| Ella Nelson | Women's Swimming | 1st | |
| Owayne Owens | Men's Track & Field | 1st | |
| Ben Vander Plas | Men's Basketball (At-Large) | 1st | |
| Derek Johnson | Men's Track & Field | 2nd | |
| Natasha Subhash | Women's Tennis | 2nd | |
| Iñaki Montes de la Torre | Men's Tennis | 2nd | |
| Gretchen Walsh | Women's Swimming | 2nd |
* Denotes At-Large Academic All-America of the Year