| Tim Burcham | 1985 | 2nd | P | Baseball America |
| Brian Buchanan | 1994 | 1st | OF | Baseball America |
| | 2nd | OF | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| Seth Greisinger | 1996 | 1st | P | ABCA |
| | 1st | P | Baseball America |
| | 1st | P | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| Joe Koshansky | 2004 | 1st | UTL | College Baseball Insider |
| | 2nd | UTL | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| | 2nd | UTL | USA Today Sports Weekly |
| | 3rd | UTL | Baseball America |
| Ryan Zimmerman | 2004 | HM | 3B | College Baseball Insider |
| 2006 | 2nd | 3B | Baseball America |
| | 3rd | 3B | NCBWA |
| Sean Doolittle | 2006 | 2nd | UTL | ABCA All-American |
| | 2nd | UTL | Baseball America |
| | 2nd | 1B | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| | 2nd | UTL | College Baseball Insider |
| | 2nd | UTL | NCBWA |
| 2007 | 2nd | UTL | Rivals.com |
| | 3rd | RHP | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| Michael Schwimer | 2007 | 1st | SP | NCBWA |
| Jacob Thompson | 2007 | 1st | RHP | ABCA |
| | 1st | RHP | Baseball America |
| | 1st | RHP | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| | 1st | SP | College Baseball Insider |
| | 1st | SP | NCBWA |
| | 1st | SP | Rivals.com |
| Danny Hultzen | 2009 | 1st | UTL | ABCA |
| | 2nd | UTL | NCBWA |
| | 3rd | UTL | Baseball America |
| 2010 | 1st | LHP | ABCA |
| | 1st | RHP | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| | 1st | SP | NCBWA |
| | 1st | LHP | Rivals.com |
| | 2nd | LHP | Baseball America |
| 2011 | 1st | LHP | ABCA |
| | 1st | UTL | Baseball America |
| | 1st | UTL | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| | 1st | UTL | NCBWA |
| | 1st | UTL | Perfect Game |
| Jarrett Parker | 2009 | 1st | OF | Rivals.com |
| | 2nd | OF | ABCA |
| | 2nd | OF | Baseball America |
| | 2nd | OF | NCBWA |
| | 3rd | OF | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| Kevin Arico | 2010 | 1st | RHP | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| | 1st | UTL | NCBWA |
| | 2nd | RHP | ABCA |
| Phil Gosselin | 2010 | 3rd | OF | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| | 3rd | OF | NCBWA |
| John Hicks | 2011 | 3rd | C | ABCA |
| | 3rd | C | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| Branden Kline | 2011 | 2nd | RHP | ABCA |
| | 2nd | RHP | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| | 2nd | RP | NCBWA |
| | 2nd | RP | Perfect Game |
| Will Roberts | 2011 | 2nd | SP | NCBWA |
| Kyle Crockett | 2013 | 3rd | RP | NCBWA |
| Mike Papi | 2013 | 1st | OF | ABCA |
| | 1st | OF | Baseball America |
| | 2nd | OF | Perfect Game |
| 2014 | 2nd | DH | Perfect Game |
| Nick Howard | 2014 | 1st | LHP | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| | 2nd | RP | ABCA |
| Nathan Kirby | 2014 | 1st | SP | ABCA |
| | 1st | SP | Baseball America |
| | 1st | LHP | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| | 1st | SP | Perfect Game |
| | 2nd | SP | NCBWA |
| | 2nd | RP | Perfect Game |
| Matt Thaiss | 2015 | 3rd | C | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| | 3rd | C | NCBWA |
| 2016 | 2nd | SP | Baseball America |
| | 3rd | C | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| | 3rd | C | NCBWA |
| | 3rd | DH | Perfect Game |
| Adam Haseley | 2016 | 3rd | UTL | Baseball America |
| | 3rd | UTL | NCBWA |
| | 3rd | UTL | Perfect Game |
| 2017 | 1st | OF | ABCA |
| | 1st | OF | Baseball America |
| | 2nd | UTL | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| | 2nd | UTL | NCBWA |
| | 2nd | UTL | Perfect Game |
| Connor Jones | 2016 | 1st | SP | ABCA |
| | 1st | SP | NCBWA |
| | 1st | SP | Perfect Game |
| | 2nd | SP | Baseball America |
| | 2nd | RHP | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| Tommy Doyle | 2017 | 3rd | RP | NCBWA |
| Andy Weber | 2018 | 3rd | 2B | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| Zach Gelof | 2020 | 2nd | 3B | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| Chris Newell | 2020 | 2nd | OF | Collegiate Baseball/Louisville Slugger |
| Jake Gelof | 2022 | 2nd | 3B | ABCA |
| | 2nd | 3B | Perfect Game |
| | 3rd | 3B | Collegiate Baseball Newspaper |
| | 3rd | 3B | NCBWA |
| | 3rd | 3B | D1Baseball.com |
| | 3rd | 3B | Baseball America |
| Devin Ortiz | 2022 | 2nd | UTL | Collegiate Baseball Newspaper |
| | 2nd | UTL | NCBWA |
| Alex Tappen | 2022 | 3rd | OF | NCBWA |
