| MALE PLAY OF THE YEAR RECIPIENTS | FEMALE PLAYER OF THE YEAR RECIPIENTS | |||||
| YEAR | NAME/PLAY | SPORT | YEAR | NAME/PLAY | SPORT | |
| 2018-19 | Unknown | 2018-19 | Paige Madden | Swimming | ||
| 2019-20 | Unknown | 2019-20 | Unknown | |||
| 2020-21 | Unknown | 2020-21 | Unknown | |||
| 2021-22 | Alex Rode | Lacrosse | 2021-22 | Michaela Meyer | Track & Field | |
| 2022-23 | Jeffery von der Schulenburg | 2022-23 | Kate Douglass | Swimming | ||
| 2023-24 | Matthew Nunes | Lacrosse | 2023-24 | Margot Appleton | Track & Field | |
| 2024-25 | First DMR Indoor NCAA title in program history | Men's Indoor Track & Field | 2024-25 | Virginia 200 Medley Relay NCAA Championship | Swimming | |
| 2025-26 | Game vs. Florida State | Football | 2025-26 | NCAA Record in 400m free ro cap NCAA Champs | Swimming | |
