| William Strickling | 1915 | 1st | — |
| Buzzy Wilkinson | 1955 | 1st | Converse |
| | 3rd | Associated Press |
| Barry Parkhill | 1972 | 1st | Converse |
| | 1st | US Basketball Writers Association |
| | 2nd | Associated Press |
| | 2nd | United Press International |
| | 3rd | National Association of Basketball Coaches |
| 1973 | 2nd | Converse |
| | 3rd | National Association of Basketball Coaches |
| Jeff Lamp | 1980 | 3rd | United Press International |
| 1981 | 1st | US Basketball Writers Association |
| | 2nd | United Press International |
| | 3rd | Associated Press |
| | 3rd | National Association of Basketball Coaches |
| Ralph Sampson | 1980 | 2nd | Converse |
| 1981 | 1st | Associated Press |
| | 1st | United Press International |
| | 1st | Converse |
| | 1st | National Association of Basketball Coaches |
| | 1st | US Basketball Writers Association |
| | 1st | Sporting News |
| 1982 | 1st | Associated Press |
| | 1st | United Press International |
| | 1st | Converse |
| | 1st | National Association of Basketball Coaches |
| | 1st | US Basketball Writers Association |
| | 1st | Sporting News |
| 1983 | 1st | Associated Press |
| | 1st | United Press International |
| | 1st | Converse |
| | 1st | National Association of Basketball Coaches |
| | 1st | US Basketball Writers Association |
| | 1st | Sporting News |
| Sean Singletary | 2007 | 3rd | National Association of Basketball Coaches |
| | 3rd | CollegeHoops.net |
| Mike Scott | 2012 | 3rd | Sporting News |
| | 3rd | Basketball Times |
| Justin Anderson | 2015 | 2nd | National Association of Basketball Coaches |
| Malcolm Brogdon | 2015 | 2nd | Associated Press |
| | 2nd | National Association of Basketball Coaches |
| | 2nd | US Basketball Writers Association |
| | 2nd | USA Today |
| | 2016 | 1st | Associated Press |
| | 1st | National Association of Basketball Coaches |
| | 1st | US Basketball Writers Association |
| | 1st | Sporting News |
| | 2nd | USA Today |
| | 2nd | Sports Illustrated |
| Kyle Guy | 2018 | 3rd | Associated Press |
| | 3rd | National Association of Basketball Coaches |
| 2019 | 2nd | USA Today |
| | 3rd | Associated Press |
| | 3rd | Sporting News |
| | 3rd | Sports Illustrated |
| | 3rd | National Association of Basketball Coaches |
| De'Andre Hunter | 2019 | 2nd | National Association of Basketball Coaches |
| | 3rd | Associated Press |
| | 3rd | Sporting News |
| | 3rd | Sports Illustrated |
| | 3rd | US Basketball Writers Association |
| | 3rd | USA Today |
