| Athlete | Year | Event |
|---|---|---|
| Ray Quillen | 1954 | HJ |
| Henry Davenport | 1957 | PV |
| 1958 | PV | |
| Clarence Roberts | 1958 | PV |
| Mike Harvey | 1968 | LJ |
| 1969 | TJ | |
| Jim Shannon | 1970 | LJ |
| Kent Merritt | 1972 | 60y |
| 1973 | 60y | |
| Keith Witherspoon | 1975 | TJ |
| 1976 | TJ | |
| Greg Canty | 1977 | 1000y |
| 1978 | 1000y | |
| 1979 | 1000y | |
| 1980 | 1000y | |
| Herman Moore | 1988 | HJ |
| 1990 | HJ | |
| Paul Ereng | 1989 | 800m |
| Ben Kurgat | 1989 | 400m |
| 1991 | 800m | |
| 1992 | 800m | |
| Cornell Grayson | 1991 | TJ |
| Thom McKinney | 1991 | SP |
| Michael Murphy | 1993 | WT |
| Rob Cook | 1993 | 3000mSC |
| 1994 | 3000m | |
| McGavock Dunbar | 2005 | 800m |
| Ryan Collins | 2009 | 5000m |
| 2010 | 5000m | |
| 2011 | 50000m | |
| Robby Andrews | 2010 | 800m |
| Anthony Kostelac | 2011 | 800m |
| Marcus Robinson | 2011 | TJ |
| 2012 | TJ | |
| Mark Amirault | 2012 | 5000m |
| Payton Hazzard | 2015 | 400m |
| Filip Mihaljevic | 2015 | SP |
| 2016 | SP | |
| 2017 | SP | |
| Jordan Young | 2015 | WT |
| 2017 | WT | |
| Henry Wayne | 2016 | Mile |
| Jack Lint | 2017 | Hep |
| Jordan Scott | 2017 | TJ |
| 2019 | TJ | |
| 2020 | TJ | |
| Brenton Foster | 2020 | HJ |
| Sam Young | 2020 | PV |
| Derek Pekar | 2020 | Hep |
| Owayne Owens | 2021 | TJ |
| 2022 | TJ | |
| Gary Martin | 2025 | 3000m |
| 2026 | 3000m | |
| Jeremiah Nubbe | 2025 | WT |
| Nikolaos Polychroniou | 2026 | WT |
| Virginia Relay | 1972 | Mile Relay |
| 1978 | Two Mile Relay | |
| 1979 | Two Mile Relay | |
| 2010 | DMR | |
| 2015 | DMR | |
| 2016 | DMR | |
| 2024 | DMR |
