| José Bauza | 1978 | HM | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 1979 | HM | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Jeff Gaffney | 1983 | 1st | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 1984 | 1st | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | F | Soccer America |
| 1985 | 2nd | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Jeff Agoos | 1986 | 3rd | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 1988 | 1st | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | D | Soccer America |
| 1989 | 2nd | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 1990 | 1st | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | D | Soccer America |
| George Gelnovatch | 1986 | 1st | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | F | Soccer America |
| John Harkes | 1986 | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 1987 | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Bob Willen | 1987 | 1st | G | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Tony Meola | 1988 | 1st | G | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 1989 | 1st | G | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | G | Soccer America |
| Curt Onalfo | 1989 | 1st | D | Soccer America |
| Erik Ilmer | 1991 | 1st | D | Soccer America |
| | 2nd | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 1992 | 1st | M | Soccer America |
| | 2nd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Claudio Reyna | 1991 | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | M | Soccer America |
| 1992 | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | M | Soccer America |
| 1993 | 1st | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | F | Soccer America |
| Brian Bates | 1992 | 1st | D | Soccer America |
| 1993 | 1st | D | Soccer America |
| Ben Crawley | 1992 | 1st | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Clint Peay | 1992 | 2nd | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Jeff Causey | 1993 | 2nd | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Nate Friends | 1993 | 1st | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Brandon Pollard | 1993 | 1st | D | Soccer America |
| | 2nd | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 1994 | 1st | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | D | Soccer America |
| 1995 | 1st | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Mike Fisher | 1994 | 1st | M | Soccer America |
| | 2nd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 1995 | 1st | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 1996 | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Damian Silvera | 1994 | 1st | M | Soccer America |
| 1995 | 2nd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| A.J. Wood | 1994 | 1st | F | Soccer America |
| | 3rd | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Matt Chulis | 1996 | 2nd | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 1997 | 2nd | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 1998 | 1st | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Ben Olsen | 1997 | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | M | Soccer America |
| Scott Vermillion | 1997 | 3rd | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Chris Albright | 1998 | 1st | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Jason Moore | 1998 | 2nd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Ryan Trout | 1999 | 3rd | M/F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Kyle Martino | 2000 | 3rd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | M | Soccer America |
| Alecko Eskandarian | 2001 | 2nd | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 2002 | 1st | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | F | Soccer America |
| Nico Colaluca | 2004 | 3rd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 2005 | 2nd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Hunter Freeman | 2004 | 1st | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Matt Oliver | 2004 | 1st | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Diego Restrepo | 2009 | 1st | G | Soccer America |
| Tony Tchani | 2009 | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 2nd | M | Soccer America |
| Eric Bird | 2013 | 2nd | M | Soccer America |
| | 3rd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 2014 | 2nd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Edward Opoku | 2016 | 2nd | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Jean-Christophe Koffi | 2017 | 1st | M | TopDrawerSoccer.com |
| Joe Bell | 2019 | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | M | Soccer America |
| | 1st | M | TopDrawerSoccer.com |
| Daryl Dike | 2019 | 2nd | F | TopDrawerSoccer.com |
| | 3rd | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 3rd | F | Soccer America |
| Henry Kessler | 2019 | 2nd | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 2nd | D | Soccer America |
| Colin Shutler | 2019 | 1st | G | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | G | Soccer America |
| Stephen Annor Gyamfi | 2023 | 1st | F | TopDrawerSoccer.com |
| | 3rd | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Mouhameth Thiam | 2023 | 2nd | M | TopDrawerSoccer.com |
