| Baseball | Brian O'Connor | 2004 | College Baseball Insider National Coach of the Year |
| | 2006 | CBF National Coach of the Year |
| | 2009 | College Baseball Insider National Coach of the Year |
| | | NCBWA National Coach of the Year |
| | 2015 | ABCA National Coach of the Year |
| | | Baseball America National Coach of the Year |
| | | Collegiate Baseball National Coach of the Year |
| | | D1Baseball National Coach of the Year |
| | | Perfect Game National Coach of the Year |
| Men’s Basketball | Tony Bennett | 2014-15 | USBWA National Coach of the Year |
| | 2017-18 | Naismith National Coach of the Year |
| | | Associated Press National Coach of the Year |
| | | USBWA National Coach of the Year |
| | | NABC National Coach of the Year |
| | | USA Today National Coach of the Year |
| Football | George Welsh | 1991 | Bobby Dodd Coach of the Year |
| Men’s Lacrosse | Dom Starsia | 2011 | — |
| Men’s Soccer | Bruce Arena | 1993 | National Coach of the Year |
| George Gelnovatch | 2009 | National Coach of the Year |
| | | Soccer America National Coach of the Year |
| Men’s Tennis | Brian Boland | 2008 | ITA National Coach of the Year |
| | 2016 | ITA National Coach of the Year |
| Andres Pedroso | 2022 | ITA National Coach of the Year |
| | 2023 | ITA National Coach of the Year |
| Women’s Basketball | Debbie Ryan | 1991 | Naismith National Coach of the Year |
| Field Hockey | Missi Sanders | 1997 | NFHCA National Coach of the Year |
| Michele Madison | 2006 | WomensFieldHockey.com National Coach of the Year |
| Women’s Golf | Kim Lewellen | 2011 | LGPA National Coach of the Year |
| Women’s Lacrosse | Jane Miller | 1991 | IWLCA National Coach of the Year |
| Julie Myers | 2004 | IWLCA National Coach of the Year |
| Rowing | Kevin Sauer | 2010 | CRCA National Coach of the Year |
| | 2012 | CRCA National Coach of the Year |
| Women's Soccer | Lauren Gregg | 1990 | NSCAA National Coach of the Year |
| Steve Sawnson | 2013 | NSCAA National Coach of the Year |
| Women's Swimming | Todd DeSorbo | 2021 | CSCAA Division I Coach of the Year |
| Todd DeSorbo | 2022 | CSCAA Division I Coach of the Year |
| Todd DeSorbo | 2023 | CSCAA Division I Coach of the Year |
| Todd DeSorbo | 2024 | CSCAA Division I Coach of the Year |
