| Boxing | Bob Goldstein | 1932 | 135 lbs. |
| Louis Schmidt | 1937 | 175 lbs. |
| Maynard Harlow | 1938 | 145 lbs. |
| Louis Schmidt | 1938 | 175 lbs. |
| Anthony Dibiase | 1955 | 165 lbs. |
| Dixon Brooke | 1940 | 156 lbs. |
| Men's Golf | Kenneth Rathbun | 1942 | |
| Men's Indoor Track & Field | Paul Ereng | 1989 | 800m |
| Robby Andrews | 2010 | 800m |
| Henry Wynne | 2016 | Mile |
| Jordan Scott | 2019 | TJ |
| Men's Outdoor Track & Field | Paul Ereng | 1988 | 800m |
| Paul Ereng | 1989 | 800m |
| Robby Andrews | 2011 | 800m |
| Filip Mihaljevic | 2016 | SP |
| | 2017 | SP |
| | | Discus |
| Claudio Romero | 2022 | Discus |
| Men's Swimming & Diving | Shanek Pietucha | 1999 | 200 Fly |
| Ed Moses | 2000 | 100 Breast |
| | | 200 Breast |
| Matt McLean | 2011 | 500 Free |
| Men's Tennis | Somdev Davvarman | 2007 | Singles |
| | 2008 | Singles |
| Dominic Inglot & Michael Shabaz | 2009 | Doubles |
| Drew Courtney & Michael Shabaz | 2010 | Doubles |
| Jarmere Jenkins & Mac Styslinger | 2013 | Doubles |
| Ryan Shane | 2015 | Singles |
| Thai Kwiatkowski | 2017 | Singles |
| Women's Cross Country | Lesley Welch | 1982 | |
| Women's Outdoor Track & Field | Michaela Meyer | 2021 | 800m |
| Rowing | Second Varsity Eight | 1988 | |
| Second Varsity Eight | 1999 | |
| Varstiy Four | 2004 | |
| Varstiy Four | 2005 | |
| Second Varsity Eight | 2005 | |
| Varstiy Four | 2007 | |
| Varstiy Four | 2010 | |
| Varsity Eight | 2012 | |
| Women's Swimming & Diving | Cara Lane | 2000 | 1500 Free |
| | 2001 | 1650 Free |
| Leah Smith | 2015 | 500 Free |
| | | 1650 Free |
| | 2016 | 500 Free |
| | | 1650 Free |
| Kate Douglass | 2021 | 50 Free |
| | 2022 | 50 Free |
| | | 100 Fly |
| | | 200 Breast |
| | 2023 | 100 Fly |
| | | 100 Breast |
| | | 200 IM |
| Paige Madden | 2021 | 200 Free |
| | | 500 Free |
| Alex Walsh | 2021 | 200 IM |
| | 2022 | 200 Fly |
| | | 200 IM |
| | | 400 IM |
| | 2023 | 400 IM |
| Gretchen Walsh | 2022 | 100 Free |
| | 2023 | 100 Free |
| | | 100 Back |
| Virginia Relay | 2021 | 800 Free |
| | 2022 | 200 Free |
| | | 400 Free |
| | | 200 Medley |
| | | 400 Medley |
| | 2023 | 200 Free |
| | | 400 Free |
| | | 800 Free |
| | | 200 Medley |
| | | 400 Medley |
| Women's Tennis | Danielle Collins | 2014 | Singles |
| | 2016 | Singles |
| Emma Navarro | 2021 | Singles |
