| Athlete | Year | Team | Organization |
|---|---|---|---|
| Donna Holt | 1987 | — | Kodak |
| — | WBCA State Farm Coaches | ||
| 1988 | — | Kodak | |
| — | WBCA State Farm Coaches | ||
| Dawn Staley | 1990 | — | Kodak |
| — | WBCA State Farm Coaches | ||
| 1991 | — | Kodak | |
| — | WBCA State Farm Coaches | ||
| — | USBWA | ||
| 1992 | — | Kodak | |
| — | USBWA | ||
| — | WBCA State Farm Coaches | ||
| Tammi Reiss | 1991 | — | Kodak |
| 1992 | — | USBWA | |
| — | WBCA State Farm Coaches | ||
| Wendy Palmer | 1995 | 2nd | Associated Press |
| 2nd | Kodak | ||
| 2nd | USBWA | ||
| 2nd | WBCA State Farm Coaches | ||
| 1996 | 2nd | Associated Press | |
| 2nd | Kodak | ||
| 2nd | USBWA | ||
| 2nd | WBCA State Farm Coaches | ||
| Tora Suber | 1997 | HM | Associated Press |
| DeMya Walker | 1999 | HM | Associated Press |
| Monica Wright | 2008 | HM | Associated Press |
| 2009 | HM | Associated Press | |
| 2010 | HM | Associated Press | |
| 1st | USBWA | ||
| 1st | WBCA State Farm Coaches | ||
| Jocelyn Wiloughby | 2020 | HM | WBCA State Farm Coaches |
| Kymora Johnson | 2025 | HM | WBCA |
