| Amanda Cromwell | 1990 | 2nd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 1991 | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Andrea Rubio | 1991 | 1st | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 1992 | 1st | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Kim Conway | 1993 | 2nd | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Danielle Desfosses | 1994 | 2nd | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Dina Padula | 1995 | 3rd | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Karem Esteva | 1997 | 2nd | D | Soccer Buzz |
| | 3rd | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Angela Hucles | 1997 | 1st | F | Soccer Buzz |
| | 2nd | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 1998 | 2nd | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 3rd | F | Soccer Buzz |
| Lori Lindsey | 1999 | HM | M | Soccer Buzz |
| 2000 | 1st | M | Soccer Buzz |
| | 1st | M | Soccer Times |
| | 3rd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 2001 | 1st | M | Soccer Times |
| | 2nd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Lindsay Gusick | 2000 | 2nd | F | Soccer Buzz |
| 2001 | 3rd | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 2004 | HM | F | Soccer Buzz |
| Katie Tracy | 2000 | HM | — | Soccer Times |
| 2001 | 1st | — | CoSIDA |
| Kelly Worden | 2002 | 3rd | D | Soccer Buzz |
| Kelly Hammond | 2003 | 2nd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 2nd | M | Soccer Buzz |
| | 2nd | M | Soccer Times |
| Becky Sauerbrunn | 2003 | 1st | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 2nd | D | Soccer Buzz |
| | 3rd | D | Soccer Times |
| 2005 | HM | D | Soccer Buzz |
| 2006 | 2nd | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 3rd | D | Soccer Buzz |
| 2007 | 1st | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 2nd | D | Soccer Buzz |
| Gillian Hatch | 2004 | 1st | — | CoSIDA |
| Sarah Huffman | 2004 | 1st | M | Soccer Buzz |
| | 2nd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 2nd | M | Soccer Times |
| 2005 | 2nd | M | Soccer Buzz |
| | 2nd | M | Soccer Times |
| | 3rd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Noelle Keslica | 2005 | 3rd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 3rd | M | Soccer Times |
| Jess Rostedt | 2005 | HM | F | Soccer Buzz |
| 2006 | 3rd | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Nikki Krzysik | 2007 | 1st | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | D | Soccer Buzz |
| 2008 | 1st | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| | 1st | D | Soccer Buzz |
| Sinead Farrelly | 2008 | 3rd | M | Soccer Buzz |
| 2009 | 2nd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 2010 | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Chantel Jones | 2010 | 4th | G | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Morgan Brian | 2011 | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 2013 | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 2014 | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Caroline Miller | 2011 | 3rd | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 2012 | 1st | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Danielle Colaprico | 2013 | 3rd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 2014 | 1st | M | CoSIDA |
| | 2nd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Makenzy Doniak | 2013 | 1st | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 2014 | 1st | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 2015 | 1st | F | CoSIDA |
| | 2nd | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Emily Sonnett | 2014 | 3rd | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 2015 | 1st | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Alexis Shaffer | 2016 | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Phoebe McCleron | 2018 | 3rd | D | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Meghan McCool | 2019 | 2nd | F | CoSIDA |
| | 3rd | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Lia Godfrey | 2020 | 2nd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 2021 | 2nd | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| 2022 | 1st | M | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
| Diana Ordoñez | 2021 | 1st | F | NSCAA/United Soccer Coaches |
