2025 (at Butler):
- Appeared in all 17 matches with nine starts in the defensive back line
- Tallied one assist at DePaul (10/3)
- Recorded six shots over the season with two on frame
- CSC Academic All-District.
2024 (at Butler) - Appeared in 14 matches with one start
- Dished out his first collegiate assist vs. Evansville (9/10)
- Joined the starting lineup at Seton Hall (10/12).
2023 (at Butler): - Made his first collegiate appearance vs. Providence (10/21).
2022 (at Butler): - Did not appear in any matches.
PRIOR TO BUTLER: - A three-year varsity starter at Chatham High School,
- Two-time all-state selection and a three-time all-county and all-conference honoree.
- Captain and MVP his final two seasons
- Tallied two goals and four assists during his high school career and was listed on the honor roll on four occasions.
- Tolkin's STA Morris United club teams were ECNL national finalists, five-time State Cup winners, ECNL league winners, and three-time US Club Soccer finalists.